Rankings, head-to-head comparisons and money-saving advice from people who've sailed to all of them.
RankingsCruise line private islands range from serene crescent beaches to full-blown water-park destinations. After visiting them all, here's how the major ones actually stack up — and which is right for your trip.
11 min read · Updated May 2026
ComparisonsTwo of the most talked-about private islands, two completely different philosophies. Here's how MSC's serene Ocean Cay and Royal Caribbean's amenity-packed Perfect Day at CocoCay actually compare.
PlanningWhat you carry off the ship makes or breaks a private island day. Here's the universal checklist — plus the island-specific extras most people forget.
PlanningCabanas are the biggest single splurge on most private islands. Sometimes they're worth every dollar — and sometimes a free lounger and a clamshell will do. Here's how to decide.
PlanningPrivate islands are designed to upsell you — but the included experience is genuinely good. Here's how to have a fantastic day for little or nothing extra.